You May Like
1888 Old Judge N172 #2-4 Charles Alcott ~~ Trimmed/Skinned ~~ St. Louis
$145.99
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Charles Hoover - PSA Authentic Chicago HIGH END
$359.95
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Cigarettes John Clarkson SGC 10 POOR 1 HOF
$1299.99
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Frank Wells Milwaukee GRADED PSA Authentic Altered RARE
$449.98
View Details
RARE 1887 1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card JOHN BARNES MGR. ST PAULS SGC 1.5
$995.00
View Details
N172 OLD JUDGE TYPE REPRINT BASEBALL CARD SET SERIES 3
$13.95
View Details
1889 N172 Old Judge Ed Delahanty SGC 3 HOF
$29950.00
View Details
N172 OLD JUDGE TYPE REPRINT BASEBALL CARD SET SERIES 4
$13.95
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #338-3 Al Meyers SGC 1
$410.00
View Details
1886-87 N172 Old Judge #502-3 Ned Williamson SGC 2 GOOD (30) Chicago
$424.95
View Details
N172 Old Judge Billy Hamilton HOF SGC 4
$13500.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #304-2 Bill McClellan – Catch SGC Authentic BOLD
$399.95
View Details
1886-87 N172 Old Judge Mike Dorgan #132-16 SGC 3.5
$600.00
View Details
1887 1889 N172 Old Judge 490-2 pose Buck West PSA 1.5 Minneapolis
$485.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Billy Sunday (446-1) PSA 2 - Baseball Evangelist
$2475.00
View Details
1887-1889 N172 Old Judge Walt Wilmot Tobacco Baseball Card Washington Rebacked
$299.99
View Details
1887 N172 OLD JUDGE DUKE P. MINNEAPOLIS POOR
$299.99
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Con Daley Throw, Right Hand Head High PSA 2
$400.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #252-2 Keefe Pitch Hands Chest Looking Front GD Altered Thin
$550.00
View Details
1887 1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card JAMES MCQUAID Denver SGC 2.5
$795.00
View Details
1887 N172 OLD JUDGE P. GUS KROCK VINTAGE CHICAGO BASEBALL CARD FLAWS GOOD MINUS
$269.99
View Details
N172 OLD JUDGE 1886-1890 UNCUT REPRINT SHEET X: Geo. Van Haltren +19 other cards
$9.95
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #482-5 Count Weber - R. Hand Chin High VG Altered Re-Backed
$247.50
View Details
1887 1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card PHILLIP KNELL ST. JOSEPHS SGC Authentic
$495.00
View Details
N172 OLD JUDGE TYPE REPRINT BASEBALL CARD SET SERIES 1
$13.95
View Details
1887 1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card BUCK WEST Minneapolis SGC 3 VG
$995.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Dave Foutz Portrait In Striped Cap PSA A - Browns Champions
$560.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #225-4b Ed Herr PSA 3 Bat in R/Hand at side Milwaukees
$800.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #346-5 Hugh Nicol – Leaning Forward Hands Out - VG-EX
$660.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #205-1 Joe Gunson SGC 1.5 Kansas City Cowboys
$800.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #425-5 Germany Smith – Throw Right Hand Chin High - GD
$385.00
View Details
1886-87 N172 OLD JUDGE #45-1 CALIFORNIA BROWN - SGC 4
$805.50
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #171-5 Julie Freeman – Pitch Right Hand Extended - PR
$330.00
View Details
Rare! 1887 Old Judge N172 OLD HOSS RADBOURN /BILLY NASH TAGGING PLAYER -PSA AUTH
$6400.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge 254 Mike King Kelly SGC Authentic Bat at Ready
$4999.95
View Details
Legendary Umpire/Manager! 1887 Old Judge N172 - 'WATCH' BURNHAM - SGC 10 PR 1
$585.00
View Details
N172 OLD JUDGE TYPE REPRINT BASEBALL CARD SET SERIES 2
$13.95
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #366-4 Fred Pfeffer - Chicago Cubs
$325.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Goodwin Baseball Card MIKE TIERNAN New Yorks SGC 4 VG/EX
$1195.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #511-4 Chief Zimmer – Throw - PR (Short) Paperloss on back
$275.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge John Patsy Cahill # SGC 3
$820.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Cy Sutcliffe Looking At Ball By Bat PSA 3 P1315
$550.00
View Details
1887 1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card JACK FARRELL BALTIMORES SGC 3 VG
$895.00
View Details
1889 N172 OLD JUDGE SHORTY RADFORD 378-5 SGC 3 VG
$499.95
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #192-2 Kid Gleason – Bat at Ready - PR
$770.00
View Details
💥 Sir Hugh Duffy 1887 N172 Old Judge Braves HOF Rookie SGC 1.5
$1550.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #23-4 Charles Bastian – Catching, Looking Up - GD
$385.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge # Nat Hudson - SGC 40
$825.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #468-1 Larry Twitchell – Bat at Ready - GD
$330.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Bill Stemmeyer - SGC 60
$594.00
View Details
N172 OLD JUDGE 1886-1890 UNCUT REPRINT SHEET I: Pud Galvin + 19 other cards
$9.95
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Gus Albert Cleveland Throwing PSA 2
$1195.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge 486 Mickey Welch HOF SGC Authentic
$3699.95
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Bill Farmer # PSA 2
$545.00
View Details
1887 1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card MIKE SLATTERY New York SGC 3 VG
$995.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #299-3 AL MAYS - SGC 5 EX ***RARE!!!***
$1012.50
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge 182-6 pose Emil Geiss Portrait SGC A - Chicago Cubs Pitcher
$425.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Goodwin Baseball Card CY SUTCLIFFE Clevelands SGC 5 EX
$1395.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #431-1 Bill Sowders – Pitch Hands Neck High - VG
$440.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #83-5 John Coleman – Bat in Right Hand at Side - PR
$330.00
View Details
1887 N172 OLD JUDGE SAMUEL BARKLEY KANSAS CITY PSA 1 POP 1 ULTRA RARE
$525.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #71-7 Bob Caruthers – Bat at Ready Left Shoulder - GD
$990.00
View Details
N-172 OLD JUDGE PSA 6 EX-MT Daly - Chicago - POP 1 - 1 higher!
$1500.00
View Details
1886 1887 N172 Old Judge Baseball TOM DALY CHICAGO WHITE SOX SGC 1 1500+ HIT
$595.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #110-3 Edward Dailey – Bat at Ready - VG-EX
$467.50
View Details
1887-90 N172 Old Judge William Holbart Catching PR
$299.99
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #49-3 Dick Buckley – Catch Hands Chest High - PR
$330.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge FRED PFEFFER Chicago Cubs PSA 3 VG Condition
$699.00
View Details
N172 OLD JUDGE - DANNY RICHARDSON - NEW YORK GIANTS - Bat Ready @ 45 Deg. - RARE
$417.95
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Thomas Flanigan # SGC 4.5
$875.00
View Details
1887 N172 OLD JUDGE BASEBALL CARD CAPT JOHN WARD NEW YORK GIANTS HOF GOODWIN PSA
$2900.00
View Details
1986 Fritsch N172 Old Judge Reprints Kid Gleason #9
$3.42
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #418-4 Lev Shreve – Pitch Right Hand Cap High - PR
$330.00
View Details
1887-1889 Old Judge N172 #213-3 William Hanrahan SGC Authentic Minneapolis BOLD
$299.95
View Details
1888 N172 Old Judge Tobacco Wooden Box with Labels + Tax Stamp NICE!
$1599.99
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #372-6 Henry Porter - Kansas City Cowboys
$335.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #298-6 Al Maul – Catch Leaning Left - PR
$550.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #310-3 Jack McGeachy – Catch - GD
$495.00
View Details
1888 N172 Old Judge Tobacco Sam Trott Baltimores 464-5 NO Creases! Sharp Image!
$2899.99
View Details
MANN, R.F., St. Louis Browns/Cardinals ~ N172 OLD JUDGE 1886-1890 REPRINT
$2.50
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Jocko Milligan # SGC 4
$1065.00
View Details
1888 N172 Old Judge Mike Dorgan #132-5 SGC Authentic CRAZY CLEAR IMAGE
$750.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #170-5 Dave Foutz – Ready to Pitch - PR
$495.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #173-3 William Fuller – Throw - GD
$440.00
View Details
JOHN McCARTY, Kansas City Cowboys (Amer. Assn.) ~ N172 OLD JUDGE 1886-90 REPRINT
$2.75
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #223-4 Moxie Hengle – Catch - PR
$357.50
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge BUSTER TOMNEY Louisvilles SGC 5.5
$2499.99
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Goodwin Baseball Card JOE SOMMER BALTIMORES SGC 3.5 VG +
$1195.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Tom Daly CHICAGO (Hands on Knees) PSA 3
$1195.00
View Details
1887 N172 OLD JUDGE DICK BUCKLEY BASEBALL CARD CATCH HANDS INDIANAPOLIS PSA 3
$995.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card JOHN IRVIN WASHINGTON SGC 2
$795.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #54-1 Bob Burke – Catch, Hands at Chest - PR
$412.50
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #417-2 Otto Shomberg – Throw Hands Neck High - GD
$550.00
View Details
1889 N172 Old Judge Harry Decker #122-1 SGC 5 P1312
$750.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #376-1 Joe Quinn – Sliding - PR (Tape)
$440.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Goodwin Baseball Card JIM FOGARTY Philadelphia SGC 3.5 VG +
$2695.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge George Pinkney - SGC 5 EX
$895.50
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Bill Vinton - SGC 5.5 EX+
$1147.50
View Details
1889 N172 Old Judge #433-7 Charlie Sprague Clevelands SGC 4 None Higher POP 2
$699.99
View Details
N172 Old Judge Cabinet Card George Sleepy Townsend With Ball 1888 1/1 G&B Studio
$1299.00
View Details